Monday, August 9, 2010

Pro - Con Formative Assessment: Animal Rights

Summary:
In China, animals are being skinned alive for fur exports to the United States. Undercover investigators (PETA and Swiss Animal Protection) witnessed how the animals were inhumanely treated and were able to record the happening through a hidden camera. They observed how the animals were repeatedly beaten before they were skinned. After the process, they are thrown into a pile of carcasses, with some still alive. However, the Chinese Fur Commission and the China Leather Industry and Association claimed that the PETA reports made were inaccurate, in which they said was an "unjustified generalization." They released statements stating that they do care for the animals properly. Regardless, PETA still continues in their efforts in trying to prevent animal cruelty.

Article Link:

Proposition:
I am definitely against live animal skinning. Regardless of the claims and statements made by the fur industry, it doesn't serve as thorough evidence to prove that PETA was inaccurate. With the undercover investigators having the opportunity to witness the animals, along with the video, it is enough to say that this is 'animal cruelty.' The entire industry needs to get charged for animal cruelty acts. It's the only way to save our animals from injustice. Although they may be doing this just for business, it's the animals' lives that are at stake.

3 comments:

  1. Hey Shan #2! LOLOLOL.
    Anyways, I had just read your post and the article and I am ASTOUNDED! I even watched the video! I managed to control my feelings because I felt like crying! I AM DEFINATELY AGAINST skinning live animals! Animals do not deserve to be treated like that! Animals being put in cages, hit hard against the floor, hung, and skinning them while they are alive can truly show that what they are doing IS animal cruelty. It does not matter if it just for the company, treating animals like this shows that they don't CARE about these animals' lives.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Shaneika! My very weird but awesome friend. :D
    Okay, let me comment on your post. Ooookkkaayyy. Let me read it first. (reading it...reading it...OMG that same video you showed us after school :( so sad)
    I definitely, definitely, definitely, agree with you 110%. Like you, I don't thing that it is right to skin animals especially if they are alive. It is animal cruelty. I'm with you girl! Stay with watch you believe in and go against that bad they have done to animals.

    Okay so go on with your life after you read this sentence and my name.

    -Traci Sahagun

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Shaneika,
    Looks like your issue inspired strong feelings in your classmates :)
    Your proposition, however, needed to be a single sentence statement of position, not a paragraph of argument.
    assessment score: 2
    mrs s

    ReplyDelete